Under His Wings
A psalm for danger (91:1–2)
Psalm 91 is sixteen verses in the fourth book of the Psalms, Israel’s songbook of a hundred and fifty prayers and hymns. Psalm 91 and Psalm 23 are the two psalms people look up most often, and many know Psalm 91 by its nicknames: the soldier’s psalm, the psalm of protection, the psalm to pray when the news is bad. It has no heading in the Hebrew text. The ancient Greek translation credits it to David, but no one can be sure, and it stands just after Psalm 90, “A Prayer of Moses.”
Derek Kidner, the Old Testament commentator, called it “a psalm for danger,” for times when we are exposed, surrounded, or up against evil we cannot see. He also showed how to follow it. The psalm moves in three voices.* First a believer speaks for himself: I will say of the LORD, he is my refuge (91:1–2). Then he turns to the reader and speaks to each of us, and the “you” is singular all the way through (91:3–13). Finally God himself speaks and makes the promise his own (91:14–16). Watch for the three voices and the psalm stops sounding like one long list of guarantees. It becomes a conversation.
So what does “He who dwells in the shelter of the Most High” mean? It describes where a person lives. The word for shelter, seter, is a hiding place, the covert where something is kept out of sight. “Will abide” translates lun, the ordinary verb for staying the night. Jacob lodged at Bethel with a stone for a pillow (Genesis 28:11). Ruth said to Naomi, “where you lodge I will lodge” (Ruth 1:16). The psalm’s first picture is not a fortress on a hill. It is a traveler on a dangerous road who has somewhere safe to sleep tonight.
Four names for God crowd into the first two verses: the Most High, the Almighty, the LORD, and my God. Kidner thought each one did work. “Most High is a title which cuts every threat down to size.” Shaddai, the Almighty, is the name by which God kept the homeless patriarchs (Exodus 6:3). The LORD is the covenant name given to Moses. And “my God” makes the general word personal.*
“My refuge and my fortress” (91:2)
Verse 2 is a vow. “I will say to the LORD, ‘My refuge and my fortress, my God, in whom I trust.’” A machseh is a refuge, a place to run to. A metsudah is a stronghold, and it has a history. It is the word for the rock fastness where David hid from Saul (1 Samuel 22:4), and for the stronghold of Zion that David took and made his city (2 Samuel 5:7).
Notice the order. The psalm does not begin by telling us what God will do. It begins with one person saying what God already is to him. Calvin, the Geneva reformer, thought that order was the point. A teacher can only pass on what he holds himself: “we cannot communicate true knowledge unless we deliver it not merely with the lips, but as something which God has revealed to our own hearts.”* The promises in verses 3 to 13 come from a man who has already run for cover.
Spurgeon, the Victorian London preacher, pressed the same small word that opens Psalm 23. Saying God is a refuge is a fact. Saying he is mine is something else: “to say he is my refuge, is the essence of consolation.”* The psalm will make huge promises. It makes them first to a person who has said “my.”
Under his wings (91:3–4)
Verse 3 names two dangers. “For he will deliver you from the snare of the fowler and from the deadly pestilence.” The fowler, yaqush, is the bird-catcher with his hidden net (Proverbs 6:5; Jeremiah 5:26). The pestilence, dever, is plague, the word for the epidemic that swept Israel in David’s last years and killed seventy thousand (2 Samuel 24:15). One danger is a plot. The other is a disease. Neither can be seen coming. That is what the whole psalm is about.
Then comes the most tender line in it. “He will cover you with his pinions, and under his wings you will find refuge.” The word for pinion, evrah, is rare. It appears only four times, and its first use is in the Song of Moses, where the LORD is “like an eagle that stirs up its nest, that flutters over its young, spreading out its wings, catching them, bearing them on its pinions” (Deuteronomy 32:11). Boaz blessed Ruth by the God of Israel, “under whose wings you have come to take refuge” (Ruth 2:12). The verb for taking refuge there is the verb in our verse, chasah.
Spurgeon could hardly believe a writer would dare it: “Had it been invented by an uninspired man it would have verged upon blasphemy, for who should dare to apply such words to the Infinite Jehovah?” Calvin saw the same strangeness and named its reason. Nothing in God’s majesty suggests a hen with her chicks. But “in accommodation to our infirmity, he does not scruple to descend, as it were, from the heavenly glory which belongs to him.” God chooses a small picture so that small people will come close.
Augustine, the North African bishop, noticed something about hens that other birds do not show. You cannot always tell which sparrow has young. You can always tell a mother hen. Her voice goes weak and her feathers loosen, because “she weakens herself because they are weak.” Then he made the connection: “Thus since we were weak, the Wisdom of God made Itself weak, when the Word was made flesh.”* We will come back to that.
Feathers are soft. So the verse changes metal halfway through. “His faithfulness is a shield and buckler.” The shield, tsinnah, is the large body shield, the kind Goliath had carried in front of him (1 Samuel 17:7). The second word, socherah, appears nowhere else in the Bible. It seems to mean something that surrounds. And the thing that does the shielding is God’s emet, his faithfulness: the God who does what he says. The mother bird and the armored wall are the same God, tender and unbreakable at once.
The terror by night (91:5–8)
Verses 5 and 6 walk around the clock. “You will not fear the terror of the night, nor the arrow that flies by day, nor the pestilence that stalks in darkness, nor the destruction that wastes at noonday.” Night and day, darkness and noon: there is no hour of the day without its danger.
Most of these dangers strike unseen. An arrow from cover. A plague that walks in the dark. The word for “destruction,” qetev, appears only three times, and one is again the Song of Moses, among the curses of “plague and poisonous pestilence” (Deuteronomy 32:24). The ancient Greek translation read the noonday destruction as a demon, and so did the Latin text Augustine preached from. Kidner thought there was no need for that. These are poetic personifications, the way we say a disease is stalking a city.*
What the psalm promises here is freedom from fear, not a world without arrows. The verb is “you will not fear.” Matthew Henry, the English Puritan commentator, drew the line carefully: “Wisdom shall keep thee from being causelessly afraid, and faith shall keep thee from being inordinately afraid.”*
Then the sentence everyone knows. “A thousand may fall at your side, ten thousand at your right hand, but it will not come near you.” And verse 8 adds that we will see the recompense of the wicked with our own eyes. This is the verse people paste on walls in a pandemic and send to soldiers. It is also the verse that has troubled many readers, because they trusted it and the plague came near anyway.
Does Psalm 91 promise no harm? (91:7–10)
This is the question most readers bring to the psalm, so we should face it squarely. Verses 9 and 10 sound like a contract. “Because you have made the LORD your dwelling place... no evil shall be allowed to befall you, no plague come near your tent.” Does it mean that a believer who trusts God enough will never be sick, never be hurt, never die young?
No. And the reasons come from the Bible itself.
The first reason is Job. Job was the most righteous man in his world, and he lost his children, his health and his wealth. His friends read the world exactly the way some people read Psalm 91: trust God and nothing bad happens, so if something bad happened, you must not have trusted. At the end of the book God says to those friends, “you have not spoken of me what is right” (Job 42:7).
The second reason is Jesus. In Luke 21 he told his disciples, “some of you they will put to death.” Two sentences later he said, “But not a hair of your head will perish” (Luke 21:16–18). Both are true at once. Some of them will die, and none of them will be lost.
The third reason is Paul. Romans 8:28 is as sweeping as Psalm 91: all things work together for good for those who love God. A few verses later Paul lists what those things include: “tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or famine, or nakedness, or danger, or sword” (Romans 8:35). Kidner set these passages beside our psalm and drew the conclusion plainly: “This is, of course, a statement of exact, minute providence, not a charm against adversity.” What the psalm assures us is that nothing can touch God’s servant except by God’s leave.*
Calvin, writing four centuries earlier, said the same. “Troubles, it is true, of various kinds assail the believer as well as others, but the Psalmist means that God stands between him and the violence of every assault, so as to preserve him from being overwhelmed.” Henry put it in a single line. Even when trouble comes, “yet there shall be no real evil in it.” The evil the psalm promises to keep away is the evil that would destroy us, not every hard thing that will happen to us.
Not everyone has drawn the line in the same place. Spurgeon believed some saints who lived very close to God were given an unusual immunity, and that others were not sheltered in the same way because their faith was weaker. Yet even he wrote that such faith “will not in all cases ward off disease and death.”* Our reading stands with Kidner and Calvin. Making the psalm a measure of faith turns a refuge into a test, and the test is the one Job’s friends set.
Even the wording of verse 10 points the same way. The ESV says no evil “shall be allowed” to befall us. That is a fair rendering of a passive verb, and it puts the weight where the psalm puts it. Nothing comes near the tent that God has not allowed. The tent may still shake.
The devil’s Bible (91:11–13)
“For he will command his angels concerning you to guard you in all your ways. On their hands they will bear you up, lest you strike your foot against a stone.”
God sends angels, plural. Calvin noticed this and drew a gentle conclusion. The psalm does not assign one guardian angel to each believer. It “commissions the whole armies of heaven to keep watch over every individual believer.”* Hebrews says it plainly: angels are “ministering spirits sent out to serve for the sake of those who are to inherit salvation” (Hebrews 1:14).
Then something remarkable happens to these verses. They are the only Scripture the devil is ever recorded quoting. When Satan tempted Jesus in the wilderness, he took him to the pinnacle of the temple and said, “If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down, for it is written,” and he quoted Psalm 91:11–12 (Matthew 4:5–6; Luke 4:9–11).
Look at what he left out. In both Gospels the quotation drops “in all your ways.” Calvin and Henry both noticed the omission and thought it was deliberate.* The promise covers the road God sends us on. It does not cover a leap from the temple roof to make God prove himself. Jesus answered with another Scripture: “You shall not put the Lord your God to the test” (Matthew 4:7, quoting Deuteronomy 6:16).
Kidner caught the contrast in two sentences. “It was characteristic of the devil to read this promise as an invitation to arrogance.” It was characteristic of God, Father and Son, to send angelic help when it was most needed, after the temptation (Matthew 4:11) and in Gethsemane (Luke 22:43), and for Jesus to refuse it when it would only have served himself (Matthew 26:53).*
So Psalm 91 can be misused, and the first person to misuse it was the devil. Tim Keller, the Manhattan pastor, preaching on this psalm, drew the warning out. If we read Psalm 91 as a promise that trust in God means nothing bad will ever happen, we will one day be bitterly disappointed, and we will pull back from God just when we need him. The psalm is meant to do the opposite: “It means you must trust God in trouble, in order to become a person who can handle trouble.”*
Verse 13 ends the middle section with victory. “You will tread on the lion and the adder; the young lion and the serpent you will trample underfoot.” The adder, peten, is probably a cobra. The serpent, tannin, is the word for the creature Aaron’s staff became before Pharaoh (Exodus 7:9). Both appear together in the Song of Moses (Deuteronomy 32:33). And any reader of the Bible hears behind this verse the first promise of all, that the woman’s offspring would crush the serpent’s head (Genesis 3:15). Paul told the Romans, “The God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet” (Romans 16:20). Jesus gave his disciples authority “to tread on serpents and scorpions,” then told them not to rejoice in that but in their names being written in heaven (Luke 10:19–20).
God speaks (91:14–16)
Now the voice changes again, and God himself speaks. “Because he holds fast to me in love, I will deliver him; I will protect him, because he knows my name.”
The verb for “holds fast in love” is chashaq. It is a strong word for setting the heart on someone or something. It appears only eight times in the Old Testament. Twice it describes God’s love for Israel: “It was not because you were more in number than any other people that the LORD set his love on you and chose you” (Deuteronomy 7:7; compare 10:15). God’s love came first. Ours answers it, and God honors the answer.
Three things describe the person God protects. He loves God. He knows God’s name, which means he trusts what God has revealed of himself. And he calls on God. That is all. Kidner pointed out that as a word for a person’s love toward God, chashaq comes only here, and he summed up the three: “At bottom the bond is between helper and helpless, a matter of grace.”*
Then God makes the promises, one after another. I will deliver him. I will protect him, or more literally set him on high. I will answer him. I will be with him in trouble. I will rescue him. I will honor him. I will satisfy him with long life. I will show him my salvation.
Read verse 15 slowly. “I will be with him in trouble.” God does not say there will be no trouble. He says he will be in it with us. Keller, preaching on this psalm, called this the line that settles the whole of it: “It says I’ll protect you in trouble.”* If verses 3 to 13 meant a life with no hardship, verse 15 would make no sense. The promise is not exemption. It is company, and then rescue.
“With long life I will satisfy him.” The Hebrew is “length of days.” Calvin admitted the difficulty, since many of God’s people die young, and gave a careful answer. Long life is a real blessing, but God hands out such earthly gifts as he sees best. What marks the believer is being satisfied. The wicked never have enough days, while God’s people “are more satisfied with the short period during which they live than the wicked, though their life should be extended for thousands of years.” Augustine went further and heard eternal life in the phrase: “What is long in time, if it hath an end, satisfieth us not.”
“And show him my salvation.” The word is yeshu’ah. Moses used it at the Red Sea: “Fear not, stand firm, and see the salvation of the LORD” (Exodus 14:13). Henry heard another echo in the line, the old man in the temple who held the baby Jesus: “good old Simeon was then satisfied with long life when he could say, My eyes have seen thy salvation” (Luke 2:30).* The psalm ends not with a long life but with a sight.
The one who trusted completely
The devil was right about one thing. Psalm 91 does fit Jesus. If any man ever dwelt in the shelter of the Most High, it was him. If anyone ever set his love on God, knew his name and called on him, it was him. Readers since the early church have heard these promises as belonging first to Christ.
Watch what Jesus did with them. In the wilderness he refused to use the psalm to force God’s hand. In Gethsemane he refused to call for the angels it promised. On the cross the arrow did come near him, and the ten thousand did not fall at his side. He fell. He was the one man who had every right to claim Psalm 91, and he gave up its protection.
Keller, preaching on Psalm 91, put it simply: “Well Jesus Christ is the only person who ever completely trusted in God.”* And bad things happened to him, because through them God was bringing redemption.
Jesus used the picture of the hen for himself. Standing over Jerusalem in the last week before his death, he said, “How often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!” (Matthew 23:37). He said it in a passage about judgment coming on the city. This is the hen Augustine saw, weakening herself for her weak chicks. A mother bird shelters her young by taking the danger on herself. Keller, preaching on this psalm, described what she does: “She puts herself between the bad and her young, and she takes it in herself.”* That is how the wings of Psalm 91 finally protect us. The judgment fell on him.
And then God kept every line of verses 15 and 16 for his Son. He was with him in trouble. He delivered him from death itself. He set him on high and honored him (Philippians 2:9). Hebrews says Jesus prayed “to him who was able to save him from death, and he was heard” (Hebrews 5:7). The answer did not come by keeping him from the cross. It came on the third day.
Where the psalm leaves us
Psalm 91 hands us a short list. A place to sleep on a dangerous road. A God with four names and two pictures, a bird’s wings and a soldier’s shield. Dangers at every hour that we cannot see. A promise twisted once by the devil and kept once and for all in Christ. And God’s own voice at the end: I will be with him in trouble.
So how do we pray Psalm 91? Not as a charm to keep every arrow away, and not as a test of whether our faith is strong enough. We pray it as the one who first spoke it prayed: I will say to the LORD, my refuge. Then we walk into the day that is in front of us, with its arrows and its noon, under wings that have already taken the worst of the fire.
For the one preaching it. Most people in the room will have met Psalm 91 in one of two ways: as a promise they clung to, or as a promise that seemed to fail them. Speak to both. Name the misreading honestly, using Job and Luke 21:16–18, and then do not leave them with less than the psalm gives. Send them home with verse 15: the God who did not keep trouble away from his own Son will not leave us alone in ours.
From history. In 1854, in his first year in London, Charles Spurgeon’s neighborhood was struck by cholera. He spent his days at sickbeds and gravesides until he was exhausted and sure he was sickening himself. Walking home from a funeral, he saw a paper in a shoemaker’s window on the Dover Road with Psalm 91:9–10 written on it in a bold hand. He wrote later that the verses steadied him, and that he went back to visiting the dying “in a calm and peaceful spirit.” He told the story in his own exposition of this psalm, written years afterward. source
Worth quoting. “But if the fire, or plague, or sword, / Receive commission from the Lord / To strike his saints among the rest, / Their very pains and deaths are blest.” — Isaac Watts, the English hymn-writer, The Psalms of David Imitated (1719), Psalm 91
Sources consulted: Derek Kidner, Psalms 73–150 (Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries); John Calvin, Commentary on the Book of Psalms; Charles Spurgeon, The Treasury of David; Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible; Augustine of Hippo, Expositions on the Book of Psalms; Timothy Keller, “Prayer of Rest” (sermon on Psalm 91, 2015); Isaac Watts, The Psalms of David Imitated
Open in the full commentary reader (discussion, cross-references) →
inkling·s