inkling-s inkling·s
Commentary · Psalm 23

The Lord Is My Shepherd

Six verses, two pictures and one confession. What "The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want" means in its own words and world: a king who calls himself a sheep, rest the shepherd arranges, a valley of deep darkness walked in company, a table laid in front of enemies and mercy that pursues us home, read toward the good shepherd who laid down his life for the sheep.

A song for the whole of life (23:1)

Psalm 23 is six verses long, and for many people it is the one passage of the Bible they can say from memory. It sits in the book of Psalms, Israel's songbook of a hundred and fifty prayers and hymns, under the heading "A Psalm of David." David kept his father's sheep before he was anointed king, so the voice here knows the work from the inside.

The psalm moves in two pictures. First the LORD is a shepherd, leading one sheep through pasture, water, rough tracks and a dark ravine (23:1–4). Then he is a host, laying a table and filling a cup for a guest whose enemies can only watch (23:5–6). One sentence carries the whole of it, and it comes first: "The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want."

So what does that sentence mean? It means that the God of Israel has taken personal charge of one life. The name is the covenant name, the LORD, the God who told Moses who he was at the burning bush and then brought a nation out of Egypt (Exodus 3:14–15). The word for shepherd, ro'eh, is a working word, the man who feeds, guides and guards a flock.

It was also a royal word. Kings in the ancient world were called the shepherds of their people. When Israel's tribes came to make David king, they reminded him that the LORD had said, "You shall be shepherd of my people Israel" (2 Samuel 5:2). So here is something strange. The shepherd-king does not cast himself as the shepherd. He takes the place of the sheep.

Calvin, the Geneva reformer, thought the psalm was written in the settled years of David's reign, and he pressed exactly this point: "David, who excelled both in power and riches, nevertheless frankly confessed himself to be a poor sheep, that he might have God for his shepherd." Calvin also saw what the comparison says about God. A shepherd is a lowly figure for the Most High to take, and "He who does not disdain to stoop so low for our sake, must bear a singularly strong affection towards us."*

Then there is the smallest word. The psalm does not say the LORD is a shepherd, or Israel's shepherd, though both are true (Psalm 80:1). It says he is my shepherd. Spurgeon, the Victorian London preacher, would not let his hearers hurry past that word: "The sweetest word of the whole is that monosyllable," he wrote, and the monosyllable is "my."* Faith in this psalm is not a theory about God's care for the world. It is a person saying whose he is.

"I shall not want" (23:1)

The second half of the verse uses the verb chaser, to lack, to be without. Its most important earlier use comes at the end of the wilderness years, when Moses reminded Israel what forty years in the desert had taught them: "These forty years the LORD your God has been with you. You have lacked nothing" (Deuteronomy 2:7). Nehemiah 9:21 says it again.

So the first line already speaks the language of the exodus, and the rest of the psalm keeps speaking it. What a whole people said looking back over forty years, one man says looking forward over his own.

This is also where the most common misreading begins. "I shall not want" does not mean I will get whatever I want. Israel in the wilderness had manna, not a menu. It means I will not lack anything the shepherd knows I need. Matthew Henry, the English Puritan commentator, wrote out the fine print: "if I have not every thing I desire, I may conclude it is either not fit for me or not good for me or I shall have it in due time."*

That is not a smaller promise. It is a safer one. A shepherd who gave his sheep everything they wanted would lose the flock in a week.

Made to lie down (23:2–3)

Verse 2 has two verbs, and the LORD is the subject of both. "He makes me lie down in green pastures." The verb rabats is the ordinary word for an animal lying down at rest. Flocks lie by a well in Genesis 29:2, and in Isaiah's picture of the peaceable kingdom the leopard lies down with the young goat (Isaiah 11:6). Here the verb is causative. He makes me lie down. Rest in this psalm is not something the sheep achieves. It is something the shepherd arranges.

"He leads me beside still waters." The Hebrew is more striking than the English: waters of rest. The noun is menuchah, the word for the rest God promised Israel in the land: "you have not as yet come to the rest and to the inheritance that the LORD your God is giving you" (Deuteronomy 12:9). A later psalm uses it for the rest a hard-hearted generation never entered (Psalm 95:11).

The verb "leads," nahal, is the word for leading a flock gently to water and a place to stop. Moses sang it at the Red Sea: "you have guided them by your strength to your holy abode" (Exodus 15:13). Isaiah used it of the LORD who will "gently lead those that are with young" (Isaiah 40:11). So two lines about grass and water quietly carry the whole story of Israel. Led out. Provided for. Brought to rest.

Spurgeon heard the gentleness in it: "He does not drive us. Moses drives us by the law, but Jesus leads us by his example, and the gentle drawing of his love."*

"He restores my soul." The soul here, nephesh, is the whole living self, not a spiritual part tucked inside a body. Some versions put "life" in the margin. The verb comes from shuv, the Bible's great word for turning back, the word the prophets use for repentance. The sheep in this verse has wandered off or worn out, or both, and the shepherd brings it back.

Henry knew sheep well enough not to flatter them: "No creature will lose itself sooner than a sheep, so apt is it to go astray, and then so unapt to find the way back."* The psalm does not pretend the sheep keeps to the path by itself. It says who brings it home.

"He leads me in paths of righteousness for his name's sake." A ma'gal is a track, the rut a wheel or a flock wears into the ground. Some versions read "right paths," the tracks that actually lead somewhere. Others keep "paths of righteousness." In Israel the two were never far apart, because the right road was always the road of God's ways.

But notice the reason given. The shepherd leads well "for his name's sake." His own reputation is bound up with how his sheep fare. Calvin saw what that rules out: David says it so that "he may not ascribe any thing to his own worth or merit."* We are not led on good roads because we are good sheep. We are led because he is a good shepherd.

The valley (23:4)

Then the ground drops away. "Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil."

Start with what David does not say. He does not say if. He says even though. The valley is not a possibility to be prayed away. It is part of the route.

What is "the valley of the shadow of death"? The word is tsalmavet. As the Hebrew scribes pointed it, it joins the words for shadow and for death. Many modern scholars read it instead as one word for deep darkness, which is why some newer versions say "the darkest valley." The argument matters less than it looks. Most of its eighteen uses are in Job, for the darkness of grief and of the grave: "the gates of deep darkness" (Job 38:17). Either way, this is darkness of the kind that feels like death standing near.

So the valley is not only the deathbed. It is any ravine where the light goes and death feels close: a diagnosis, a graveside, a fear that wakes us at three in the morning. Augustine, the North African bishop, widened it further and read the whole of our mortal life this way: "Yea, though I walk in the midst of this life, which is the shadow of death."*

Then comes the sentence that holds the psalm together. "For you are with me." Up to here David has talked about the LORD. He makes me lie down. He leads me. He restores. Now, in the dark, David talks to him. He has become you.

The comfort of the valley is not an explanation of the valley. It is company. By one count of the Hebrew, "you are with me" stands almost exactly at the center of the psalm, with twenty-seven words before it and twenty-six after. Whether or not David counted, the center is the right place for it.

And "I will fear no evil" is not the boast of a man who feels nothing. Calvin was careful here: "Yet David did not mean to say that he was devoid of all fear, but only that he would surmount it so as to go without fear wherever his shepherd should lead him." Then he asked the obvious question: "What need would he have had of that consolation, if he had not been disquieted and agitated with fear?"* The comfort is for frightened sheep. Unafraid sheep would not need it.

The comfort has a shape. "Your rod and your staff, they comfort me." The rod, shevet, is the short club a shepherd carried against wolves and thieves. The same word means a king's scepter (Genesis 49:10; Psalm 45:6). The staff, mish'enet, comes from a root meaning to lean. It is the stick an old man walks with in Zechariah 8:4. One protects. One holds up.

The verb "comfort," nacham, is the word for consoling grief. Jacob "refused to be comforted" for Joseph (Genesis 37:35). Isaiah opens his promise of homecoming with "Comfort, comfort my people" (Isaiah 40:1).

Spurgeon read the shadow itself as good news: "Nobody is afraid of a shadow, for a shadow cannot stop a man's pathway even for a moment. The shadow of a dog cannot bite; the shadow of a sword cannot kill; the shadow of death cannot destroy us."* For a believer, he meant, death's substance has been dealt with. What falls across the path is only its shadow.

A table in enemy country (23:5)

Verse 5 changes the picture. The sheep becomes a guest, and the shepherd becomes a host.

"You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies." The verb is 'arakh, to set in order, to lay out. It is the word for setting the bread on the table in the tabernacle (Exodus 40:23). It is also the word for drawing up a battle line. When Saul's army faced the Philistines in the Valley of Elah, the soldiers "drew up in line of battle" (1 Samuel 17:2), and a shepherd boy named David was on his way to the camp with ten loaves for his brothers (17:17). Now the same verb lays a meal.

The enemies are still there. They are simply not in charge of the menu. Spurgeon pictured a soldier in the field who bolts his food and runs back to the fight, and set this table beside him: "Nothing is hurried, there is no confusion, no disturbance, the enemy is at the door, and yet God prepares a table, and the Christian sits down and eats as if everything were in perfect peace."*

"You anoint my head with oil." This is not the anointing word of kings and priests. That is mashach, from which the word Messiah comes. The verb here is dashen, to make rich, and the picture is hospitality. A host honored a guest by perfuming his head. Jesus reproached a Pharisee who had not done it for him: "You did not anoint my head with oil" (Luke 7:46). The oil here is not a coronation. It is a welcome.

"My cup overflows." The word for overflowing, revayah, appears only twice in the Bible: here, and in a psalm that remembers going "through fire and through water" and being brought out "to a place of abundance" (Psalm 66:12). Spurgeon told of a poor woman who broke a piece of bread, filled a glass with cold water and said, "What, all this, and Jesus Christ too?"* The overflow is not measured by what is in the cup. It is measured by who poured it.

Pursued by mercy (23:6)

"Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life." The first word can mean surely, and it can also mean only. Mercy is chesed, the covenant love God promised Israel and kept when Israel did not (Exodus 34:6).

"Follow" is far too mild. The verb is radaph, to pursue, to chase. It is what Pharaoh's chariots did to Israel at the sea (Exodus 14:9). It is what the psalmist's enemies do in psalm after psalm (Psalm 7:1; 31:15). In verse 5 the enemies sat at the edge of the table. In verse 6 David looks over his shoulder and finds that the only things chasing him are God's goodness and God's covenant love. They will not stop until the last of his days.

Henry reached back to the wilderness for an image: "It shall follow me, as the water out of the rock followed the camp of Israel through the wilderness."*

"And I shall dwell in the house of the LORD forever." Two small notes make the line richer. The Hebrew as the scribes preserved it reads "I shall return to the house of the LORD." The ancient Greek translation, and most English versions after it, read "dwell." Both point the same way: home is where the LORD is.

And "forever" is literally "for length of days," which can mean as long as I live. David does not end with a timeline. He ends with a direction. Calvin heard the direction plainly: "the mark at which he aims is fixed in heaven, and to reach this was his great object in all things."*

The shepherd who became the lamb

Psalm 23 was never meant to be read alone. It comes straight after Psalm 22, which begins, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" Jesus prayed that first line from the cross (Matthew 27:46). Spurgeon saw what the order means: "There are no green pastures, no still waters on the other side of the twenty-second psalm."* The forsaken one comes before the shepherd.

The prophets had promised that God himself would one day shepherd his scattered people. In the same breath Ezekiel promised "one shepherd, my servant David" (Ezekiel 34:23), a David still to come, long after David had died. Then Jesus stood in Jerusalem and said, "I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep" (John 10:11).

D. A. Carson, the New Testament scholar, points out how far that goes beyond any real shepherd. A good shepherd might risk his life for the flock and lose it. Nobody chooses to die for sheep, because "A human life is worth more than a flock of sheep." Jesus' claim, Carson says, "pushes the metaphor to the wall."*

So we read Psalm 23 again from the far side of the cross. I shall not want, because the shepherd went without. He restores my soul, because he went after the one that strayed (Luke 15:4). You are with me in the valley, because on the cross he was forsaken, so that his sheep would never walk the valley alone. Goodness and mercy pursue me, because what should have pursued us fell on him.

Calvin drew the line from the psalm to the gospel in one sentence. God, he wrote, "in the person of his only begotten Son, has exhibited himself to us as our shepherd, much more clearly than he did in old time to the fathers who lived under the Law."* The shepherd of Psalm 23 now has a face and a name.

The Bible's last book gives the psalm its final form: "the Lamb in the midst of the throne will be their shepherd, and he will guide them to springs of living water" (Revelation 7:17). The shepherd became the lamb, so that the lamb could be our shepherd forever.

Where the psalm leaves us

Psalm 23 hands us a short list. A shepherd who takes charge of one life. Rest he arranges. A soul he brings back. A road with a valley in it. Company in the dark. A table laid while enemies watch. Mercy that chases us home.

Most of us first heard it at a funeral, and it belongs there. But it was written for the whole road, for Tuesdays as much as for gravesides. The psalm never asks whether there will be a valley. There will be. It asks whose voice we will be talking to when we are in it.


Seen Elsewhere

For the one preaching it. Resist the urge to make Psalm 23 a funeral text only. Its center is not "you will die well" but "you are with me," and most of the people in the room are in some valley this week that is not a deathbed. Walk them through the change from he to you in verse 4, and let them hear that the psalm talks to God exactly where the light goes. Then send them home with verse 6: the only thing chasing a sheep of this shepherd is mercy.

From history. Psalm 23 is now so tied to funerals that it is easy to assume it always was. It was not. The burial service in the Church of England's Book of Common Prayer used only Psalms 39 and 90, and the American Episcopal Church did not add Psalm 23 to its funeral rite until the 1928 prayer book; its strong association with funerals in the English-speaking world belongs largely to the twentieth century. Calvin, for his part, thought David wrote it in a season of prosperity, as a guard against forgetting God when life was going well. source

Worth quoting. "There would I find a settled rest, / While others go and come; / No more a stranger or a guest, / But like a child at home." — Isaac Watts, the English hymn-writer, The Psalms of David Imitated (1719), Psalm 23

Sources consulted: John Calvin, Commentary on the Book of Psalms; Charles Spurgeon, The Treasury of David; Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible; Augustine of Hippo, Expositions on the Book of Psalms; D. A. Carson, For the Love of God, vol. 1; Isaac Watts, The Psalms of David Imitated; Derek Kidner, Psalms 1–72 (Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries)

Open in the full commentary reader (discussion, cross-references) →