But in the meantime, and in general, we ought to pay evildoers, including ourselves, the “intolerable compliment” of taking them seriously as moral agents, of holding them accountable for their wrongdoing. This is a mark of our respect for their dignity and weight as human beings. After all, what could be more arrogant than treating other persons as if they were no more responsible than tiny children or the mentally maimed?
— Cornelius Plantinga Jr., A Breviary of Sin
Ink in the margin
One way to read it, not the last word.
To hold people accountable — ourselves included — is not harshness but honor, the refusal to demote a moral agent into a helpless thing we manage rather than a person we take seriously.
Themes
More from Cornelius Plantinga Jr. on judgment
and a welfare problem and an AIDS problem and a rape problem. None of this will go away until more people in positions of responsibility are willing to come forward and explain, in frankly moral terms, that some of the things people do nowadays are wrong.
Before long it began to become clear that those whom we do not blame we do not regard as responsible. Those whom we do not regard as responsible we do not see as fully human. And those whom we do not see as fully human we are willing to twist and manipulate to suit our own convenience.
inkling·s